| 2010 - Gold Medal - Top Brewers in the World - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2010 - Gold Medal- Best Breweries to Visit - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2010 - Wisconsin Companies to Watch - Wisconsin Entrepreneurs’ Network |
| 2009 - Shared Savings Award - Alliant Energy |
| 2009 - Gold Medal- Best Breweries to Visit - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2009 - Gold Medal- Top Brewers in the World - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2009 - Top 10 Breweries - America's Best and Top 10 |
| 2009 - Gold Medal - Thirsty Troll Brewfest |
| 2009 - Madison's 5 Greenest Beers - Examiner |
| 2009 - The 25 Best American Breweries of the Decade - Paste Magazine |
| 2009 - Top 10 Midwest Craft Breweries - BeerDorks |
| 2009 - Top 100 Food and Beverage Companies - Inc. 500|5000 |
| 2009 - Top 3 Midwest Craft Breweries - The Full Pint |
| 2009 - Top 5 American Micro-Breweries - Trifter |
| 2009 - Top 50 Craft Brewing Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2009 - Top 50 Overall Brewing Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2009 - Top Twenty Craft Beer Sales - IRI |
| 2009 - Wisconsin's 10 Best Brews - Moon Travel Guide |
| 2008 - Outstanding Business of the Year - Green County Development Corporation |
| 2008 - Best Brewery - Madison Beer Review |
| 2008 - Silver Medal - Best Microbrew of Madison - Madison Magazine |
| 2008 - Silver Medal-People's Choice Award - Between the Bluffs Beer & Cheese Festival |
| 2008 - All Time Top Breweries on Planet Earth - BeerAdvocate Magazine |
| 2008 - 9 Noteworthy Breweries - Fine Living - On Television |
| 2008 - Top 10 Best Micro Brews - Men's Fitness Magazine |
| 2008 - Top 10 Midwest Breweries - BeerDorks |
| 2008 - Gold Medal- Top Brewers in the World - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2008 - Top 100 Food and Beverage Companies - Inc. 500|5000 |
| 2008 - Top 10 Breweries - America's Best and Top 10 |
| 2008 - 12 Top-Notch Midwest Breweries - Chicago Sun-Times |
| 2008 - Top 50 Craft Brewing Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2008 - Top 50 Overall Brewing Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2007 - Gold Medal- Top 3 American Breweries - SportingNews |
| 2007 - Dan Carey: Top 10 Tastemaker: Wine, Beer & Spirits - Forbes |
| 2007 - Top 50 Overall Brewing Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2007 - Top 50 Craft Brewing Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2007 - Gold Medal- People's Choice Award - Between the Bluffs Beer & Cheese Festival |
| 2007 - Gold Medal-Top Brewers in the World - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2007 - Bronze Medal - Best Microbrew of Madison - Madison Magazine |
| 2007 - 25 Best Microbreweries in the Country - TravelHacker |
| 2007 - Top 100 Food and Beverage Companies - Inc. 500|5000 |
| 2007 - Top 15 Best Portfolios - zymurgy |
| 2007 - Top 15 Breweries - zymurgy |
| 2006 - Dan Carey - Innovation in Craft Brewing - Russell Schehrer Award - Brewers Association |
| 2006 - Dan Carey, Brewer of the Year (Midsize) - Great American Beer Festival |
| 2006 - Brewery of the Year (Midsize) - Great American Beer Festival |
| 2006 - Top 50 Overall Brewing Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2006 - Top 50 'Craft Brewing' Companies - Brewers Association |
| 2006 - All Time Top 25 Breweries on Planet Earth - BeerAdvocate |
| 2006 - Top 10 Midwest Breweries - BeerDorks |
| 2006 - 10 Noteworthy Breweries - Fine Living |
| 2006 - Bronze Medal - Best of Madison-Microbrew - Madison Magazine |
| 2006 - Gold Medal- Top 100 Brewers in the World - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2005 - Brewers of the Year (Mid-Size)-New Glarus Brewers - Great American Beer Festival |
| 2005 - Brewery of the Year (Mid-Size) - Association of Brewers - Great American Beer Festival |
| 2005 - Top 50 Breweries - Brewers Association |
| 2005 - Best Local Beer - The Badger Herald |
| 2005 - 50 Best Brewers - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2005 - 50 Best Brewers - CNN/Money |
| 2004 - 10 Noteworthy Breweries (#4) - Fine Living |
| 2004 - Top 100 Brewers in the World - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2003 - Dan Carey, Brewer of the Year (Small) - Association of Brewers - Great American Beer Festival |
| 2003 - Best Small Brewery in America - Great American Beer Festival |
| 2003 - Hunger's Hope Award - Taste of the Nation |
| 2003 - Top 10 Domestic Specialty Brewers (North Central) - The New Brewer |
| 2003 - Top 50 Commercial Brewers - Modern Brewery Age |
| 2003 - Top 50 American Breweries - BeerAdvocate |
| 2003 - The World's Best Brewers - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2003 - Best North American Brewers - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2002 - Small Business of the Year - Green County Development Corporation |
| 2002 - Wisconsin's Favorite Microbrewery - Wisconsin Trails Magazine |
| 2002 - Top 50 Commercial Brewers - Modern Brewery Age |
| 2002 - 10 Breweries to Watch For - Business Magazine |
| 2002 - The World's Best Brewers - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2002 - Top North American Brewers - Rate Beer - Santa Rosa, CA |
| 2001 - Wisconsin's Best Breweries and Brewpubs: - Robin Shepard; 'Searching for the Perfect Pint' |
| 2001 - Wisconsin's Favorite Microbrewery - Wisconsin Trails Magazine |
| 2000 - Wisconsin's Favorite Microbrewery - Wisconsin Trails Magazine |
| 1999 - Wisconsin's Best Microbrewery - Wisconsin Trails Magazine |
| 1999 - Top 10 Breweries of the Year - The Beverage Testing Institute |
| 1999 - Top Ten Brewery of the Year - All About Beer Magazine |
| 1999 - Judge's Choice - Beverage - The Grande Finale |
| 1998 - Top 10 Breweries of the Year - The Beverage Testing Institute |
| 1998 - Business of the Year - Green County Development |
| 1998 - America's 20 Best Breweries - Food & Wine Magazine |
| 1998 - Brewery of the Year - Star Liquor |
| 1997 - Business of the Year - Green County Development Corporation |
| 1997 - Local Brew - Best of Madison - Madison Magazine |
| 1997 - Madison's Favorite Beer - Isthmus Newspaper |
| 1997 - Wisconsin's Best Microbrewery - Wisconsin Trails Magazine |
| 1995 - Top Ten Breweries of the Year - The Beverage Testing Institute |
| 1995 - Wisconsin's Best Microbrewery - Wisconsin Trails Magazine |
